Tolkien as author predestines Frodo to carry the ring, elects him as bearer. Still, every time I read the book, I am absolutely convinced Frodo freely chooses to carry it. Even on repeat readings. I know beforehand he will accept it. But when the moment comes I'm equally sure he chooses it freely.
Authors also often say their characters and stories surprise them.
Very interesting that you would use Tolkien as an analogy, considering his thoughts on the matter... I do it myself, also, and I catch myself contemplating the analagous nature of Tolkien's works. They are so ready for analogy, that it seems they were written that way.
It is quite easy to find fault with others.
The Bible clearly states God chooses whom he wills, some for honour and some for dishonour. (Predestination)
The Bible also clearly states we are to choose to serve God. (Free will)
Tolkien as author predestines Frodo to carry the ring, elects him as bearer. Still, every time I read the book, I am absolutely convinced Frodo freely chooses to carry it. Even on repeat readings. I know beforehand he will accept it. But when the moment comes I'm equally sure he chooses it freely.
Authors also often say their characters and stories surprise them.
Very interesting that you would use Tolkien as an analogy, considering his thoughts on the matter... I do it myself, also, and I catch myself contemplating the analagous nature of Tolkien's works. They are so ready for analogy, that it seems they were written that way.